The prop-firm industry has a trust problem. We document it.
Sim evaluators, “funded” accounts, instant payouts — the online prop-firm space exploded faster than anyone could police it. We collect reader reports, track denied payouts, moving goalposts and rule changes, and publish what the marketing pages won’t.
Latest Investigations
Read this first. Our reporting describes patterns, reader-submitted reports and matters under review — not legal verdicts. Firms named in any story are offered a right of reply, and corrections are published openly. See our editorial standards and disclaimer.
The “trailing drawdown” trap: how a winning week can still blow your account
The single most-reported source of confusion in our inbox. We break down how trailing-threshold rules actually work, why traders say they get caught off guard, and the exact questions to ask before you pay for an evaluation.
By The Desk · AnalysisRead → Payout Disputes“My payout was denied.” The five reasons readers report most
A pattern review of withdrawal-denial reports — and how to document yours.
Reports loggedRead → ExplainerWhen “funded” isn’t funded: demo accounts vs. real capital
What the word “funded” legally has to mean — and what it often doesn’t.
ExplainerRead → Tactics WatchReset farming: how repeat-challenge fees add up for the house
Why some evaluation models can profit more from failure than from funding.
MonitoringRead → Red Flags7 warning signs a prop firm’s rules are designed to make you lose
The fine-print patterns we keep seeing across reader-submitted account terms.
ChecklistRead → Marketing Watch“Affiliate-funded hype”: who profits when an influencer pushes a firm
Following the money behind the YouTube and Discord promo machine.
MonitoringRead →How we investigate
We are not a review site and we are not paid by the firms we cover. Every story follows the same chain — so what we publish can stand up to scrutiny.
Reports come in
Traders submit experiences, screenshots, account terms and payment records through our confidential tip-line.
We verify
We cross-check documents, look for patterns across multiple independent reports, and separate fact from frustration.
Right of reply
Before publishing anything about a named firm, we contact them for comment and publish their response.
We publish & correct
Stories are dated, sourced and open to correction. Get something on the record and we’ll update it.
The Watchlist
What a status means. A listing reflects the volume and nature of reader reports we’ve received and our review stage — it is not a finding of wrongdoing. “Monitoring” means we’re watching; “Complaints logged” means readers have submitted reports we’re reviewing; “Responded” means the firm has engaged with us; “Cleared” means reports were not substantiated. Firms can respond any time via our contact page.
From the inbox
Unverified, as submitted. These are reader accounts in their own words, anonymized to protect identities. They reflect individual experiences, not our findings, and have not all been independently verified.
“Passed the eval, hit my profit target, then got told a ‘rule violation’ I’d never seen in the dashboard. PFA showed me how to pull the account log and file properly.”
— Marcus D. · futures trader
“I didn’t realize ‘funded’ meant another sim account until I read the breakdown here. Saved me from upgrading to the next tier.”
— Aïcha R. · part-time trader
“Finally somewhere that isn’t an affiliate link in disguise. They actually asked the firm for a response before posting anything.”
— Dimitri K. · prop challenge buyer
Get every investigation before the firms do.
One email a week: new investigations, watchlist changes, and the red flags to check before you pay for an evaluation. No spam, no affiliate links.
Submit a confidential tip.
Denied payout? Misleading terms? Screenshots, account logs, payment records — send what you have. We protect our sources and never publish your identity without consent.
Open the Tip-LineFor sensitive material, see secure submission options on our contact page. By subscribing you agree to our Privacy Policy. We use cookies as described in our Cookie Policy.
Straight answers
Are all the firms you list scams?
No — and we never say that. A watchlist entry reflects the reports we’ve received and our review stage, not a verdict. Many firms operate legitimately. Our job is to document complaints, verify what we can, give firms a right of reply, and let readers make informed decisions.
How do you verify a report?
We look for documentary evidence (screenshots, account terms, payment records), cross-reference multiple independent reports, and contact the firm for comment before publishing anything that names them. See our editorial standards.
A firm wants to respond or request a correction. How?
Reach the desk through our contact page. We publish responses and issue corrections promptly when something is shown to be inaccurate.
Do you take money from prop firms or affiliates?
No. We don’t run affiliate links to the firms we cover and we don’t accept payment for coverage. PropFirm Alert is independent and reader-funded. Read more in our About page.
Is anything here financial or trading advice?
No. PropFirm Alert is journalism and consumer-protection reporting. Nothing on this site is financial, investment, legal or tax advice. Trading carries significant risk. See our full disclaimer.
Will you keep my identity private if I send a tip?
Yes. We protect sources and never publish your identity without your explicit consent. See secure submission options on the contact page.
Before you buy another evaluation, read the file.
Thousands of traders use PropFirm Alert to spot the red flags first. It’s free, it’s independent, and it’s on your side.